Reviews

Making Her Theirs by Lily Manning, Lily Manning

kalliss1995's review

Go to review page

2.0

If you are looking for a quick spicy read that is definitely what you get here. The sprinkling of plot alongside this was actual interesting and made it seem like more was going, but unfortunately it wasn't explored further which left me with A LOT of unanswered questions.

feelinnocane's review

Go to review page

4.0

Making Her Theirs by Lily Manning - The story starts off with meeting Georgia. After working hard at a Dallas Texas accounting firm, she finally received the promotion she has been working towards. This promotion lands her in Edinburgh, Scotland for a short stay to work on a project. After a long flight, lost luggage, and the discovery that her new furnished apartment is indeed anything but furnished, a drink at the pub downstairs from her is overdue. We are then introduced to Finn, Knox and Lachlan. From the authors description of these men, they will leave your mouth watering. When Georgia lays eyes on Knox and Finn, she knows it is over for her and she is not mad about it. Later that night she meets Lachlan when she is locked out of her apartment. Soon after she is surprised to find out not only do all three own the bar and rental, but they are also brothers. Each brother having their own personality makes you wonder if one is going to favor the other, but then you realize this is a why choose.

The Spice in this book is 4.5 out of 5. The author’s writing is very smooth, which makes this a fast read. Georgia lives out every girl's fantasy of going overseas and meeting mister tall, dark, and handsome, technically she meets 3. You get to watch the characters grow and it keeps you entertained throughout the story. And from what I can tell this may become a series. I cannot wait to read more from this author. If you like spicy books I would 100% recommend this book.


I received an Advanced Reader Copy (ARC) of this book in exchange for an honest review. This does not influence my thoughts, opinions, or the content of my review. My feedback is based solely on the merit of the book and my personal reading experience.

littlem0use's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

If you love smut and minimal plot, this book is for you! Totally my jam and I was here for all of it!

The story follows three brothers, all damaged in their own way due to their parent abandoning them. That is until they meet Georgia who walks into the bar they own and all their lives change!

Georgia is in Edinburgh for work and is only staying for a short while where she will then return back home to fulfill her desires and dreams she’s always wanted. She walks into the bar and she first meets sexy, flirty Finn and her live takes a wild ride from there!

Thank you NetGalley and Innes Field LLC for providing me with this ARC.

whatstaylor_reading's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

“She’s my castle in the sky, and it’s fucking killing me.”

Making Her Theirs is a great, short novella if you’re looking for something with a little plot, and a lot of spice.

The story begins with Georgia Henry arriving in Scotland on a work trip. Her apartment rental just happens to be above a popular bar owned by three gorgeous brothers who have their eye on her from the moment she walks into their bar. Things quickly heat up and after ten days of bliss she has to decide what to do with herself and the feelings she’s developed for all of the brothers.

I really hope the author makes her next book longer, with the plot and characters a little more fleshed out. I think that’s the only thing that stopped me from being more invested in the story and characters in this one. From the sneak peek, I think I may enjoy Killian’s story more than Georgias.

the_world_of_a_bookaholic's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Thank you Netgalley & Innes Field LLC for the ARC!

If you enjoy RH, this is a good book for you.

Georgia goes to Scotland for work for a few days and she meets three brothers. Needless to say the attraction is instant. As she gets to know the brothers she understands heach one of them fulfills particular needs she missed her entire life

The story is a quick read, the plot is very light, but every once in a while it's good to delve into pure smut and this one delivers... a lot.

starsandvellum's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Look, I'm very easy to please when it comes to smut/erotica. Was this book far-fetched? Yes. Was it original? No. Did I enjoy it? Absolutely.

Arriving in Edinburgh for 10 days to cement her place for an upcoming promotion back in Texas, Georgia runs into three brothers. What follows is a why-choose reverse harem love-fest.

I approached Making Her Theirs with little to no expectations and that definitely went in my favour. This book is more on the novella side when it comes to length (but isn't marketed that way for some reason?. So really getting to know the characters to the depth that is expected is just not possible with the length that this book is. We did get to know each of the characters based on surface level interests, but not much deeper than that. The plot is light, but still enjoyable. There wasn't any big climax to resolve so it was a light and enjoyable read.

When it comes to the characters, some of the dialogue was a little cringe and the Scottish boys calling Maths "math" kind of annoyed me as in the UK it's called maths, but I looked past that. One thing I really loved about this book was that Georgia was so comfortable in her sexuality and what she wanted. There was no "I shouldn't have done that", "why am I like this" type of inner monologue which is something I don't see too often in books that I really appreciated. The brothers' were all loveable in their own way, I'm glad it was why choose because I couldn't have chosen!

I do wish this book was longer so we COULD get to know each of the characters and really connect with the story a little more. But on the overall, it was enjoyable. I finished it in around 2 hours.

everleighrose5's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

Brothers.

lifeinthebooklane's review against another edition

Go to review page

You can spot the author has no idea about Scotland from the American names she has given her supposedly Scottish heroes

paginasdapaty's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Wow. This is a very intense romance. I read it in a few hours. And Jaysus, it's delicious, heavy, really erotic. There is little development of the character aspects, although we manage to define each person's personality well. But because it is well repeated at different points in the book, as if they were repeated excerpts. Honestly, I liked it, but it's not a book that will please the majority of the public. What ended up for me (and thank God it was in the last chapter) was an unexpected pregnancy micro trope. If it had happened before, I don't know if I would have liked it as much. I was very interested to know about the next book in the series with Killian's extra chapter. I have positive expectations that it will be a Reverse Harem with ⚔️. Lol, I'm one of those readers.


I received a e-ARC via NetGalley in exchange for a honest review. It's at KU. If you like books like this, go for it!

readerlatte's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

If you are looking for a book with a lot of spice but not a lot of plot then this could be for you. It was very fast to read and a great size for being a novella but I just wished that it could have gone a little more in depth with the story.