Scan barcode
A review by lyall_reads
The Tainted Cup by Robert Jackson Bennett
adventurous
funny
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
Din’s first dead body would be hard for anyone to forget- an Imperial officer killed by a tree sprouting from inside his body is neither a pleasant nor usual sight- but for Din, it’s literally impossible. As an Engraver, Din’s brain was altered using substances derived from the very goliaths that threaten the empire he serves to be able to remember everything he sees in perfect detail- a useful skill when working as the assistant to the empire’s best (and most eccentric) investigator, the recently disgraced Ana Dolabra. Din took the augments and the job to send money to his family, but working for Ana is not a normal experience- even before the plant-based murder. He’d have enough to handle with weathering her quirks and hiding his own secrets from her sometimes terrifying powers of observation, but the Imperial officer is not an isolated incident. As the conspiracy becomes more vast (and terrifying), the giant beasts bear down on the city’s walls. Din may be able to help Ana expose corruption in the highest levels of power, but only if he survives the threats of plant-murder, regular-murder, and being squashed by a giant monster (not to mention the existential horror of never forgetting a thing).
Creative, engaging, and so much fun! I’ve been recommending it to a lot of people, generally pitching it as Holmes and Watson, but Watson is a dyslexic bisexual disaster with low self esteem and Holmes is an agoraphobic super genius who likes to lock herself in a trunk (mostly the same) and they live in something like the Roman empire but they’re under constant threat from kaiju. Loved the magic system (it leans towards SF with the augmentations but placed in a firmly fantasy setting), loved the characters, loved the mystery.
Also, great disability representation. While I don’t have the experience to comment on how Din’s dyslexia specifically was handled, I can say that the way Bennett handled neurodivergence as a concept interacting with the fantasy elements of the world was GREAT and felt surprisingly real to me. It’s a bit of a spoiler, so I won’t get into details, but something I thought was some allegorical representation of some issues more close to home for me turned out to be literal in the last few chapters and I almost cried. It’s representation that’s neither just slapped on nor patronizing and that’s unfortunately hard to find. It ruled.
Anyway, I’m recommending this book to a lot of people. It’s very early in the year and I still think this will be hard to knock from my top five reads come this December.
Creative, engaging, and so much fun! I’ve been recommending it to a lot of people, generally pitching it as Holmes and Watson, but Watson is a dyslexic bisexual disaster with low self esteem and Holmes is an agoraphobic super genius who likes to lock herself in a trunk (mostly the same) and they live in something like the Roman empire but they’re under constant threat from kaiju. Loved the magic system (it leans towards SF with the augmentations but placed in a firmly fantasy setting), loved the characters, loved the mystery.
Also, great disability representation. While I don’t have the experience to comment on how Din’s dyslexia specifically was handled, I can say that the way Bennett handled neurodivergence as a concept interacting with the fantasy elements of the world was GREAT and felt surprisingly real to me. It’s a bit of a spoiler, so I won’t get into details, but something I thought was some allegorical representation of some issues more close to home for me turned out to be literal in the last few chapters and I almost cried. It’s representation that’s neither just slapped on nor patronizing and that’s unfortunately hard to find. It ruled.
Anyway, I’m recommending this book to a lot of people. It’s very early in the year and I still think this will be hard to knock from my top five reads come this December.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Gore
Moderate: Ableism, Body horror, and Violence