I already knew I might want to read this one because it's a thriller, but as soon as I saw that it was about influencers on a reality tv show with a little bit of murder sprinkled in, I couldn't download it fast enough. And boy, did it deliver! There's drama between the characters from the very beginning, which is juicy enough on its own, knowing said characters are about to be stuck together in the middle of nowhere for three weeks. But then the bodies start dropping, and the plot twists and turns until the very end. It's one of those books where I didn't see the ending coming, but when I think about it, all of the clues were there all along. And, as an added bonus, each of the four POV character has such a distinct voice, I never once felt like they all ran together. This book would be a great fit for fans of Karen McManus.
Thank you to Wednesday Books for providing a copy for review.
I absolutely loved this book. It took me some time to get through because, as other reviewers have pointed out, it's a pretty heavy story. But it was well worth it.
The level of detail in Bruggeman's descriptions made me forget that this book is supposed to be historical fiction. As a writer, I know how much research must have gone into accomplishing that, so I also applaud that effort.
I also found the characters to be well-developed. Many of them had to make really hard choices in order to survive, and their motivations were clear -- which made it easy to feel sympathetic. I also loved watching the dynamic between Tempa and Henry develop, and the end of the book honestly left me super in my feelings.
While Desert Phoenix isn't right for the students I work with, I know a lot of adult historical fiction readers who would love a book like this.
Content warnings: rape, drug abuse, suicide, violence, animal death, murder
Thank you to the author for providing a copy for review.
I read the first two chapters and encountered racism, classism, and fatphobia. Based on that, I feel that this is not a book that would appeal to the readers I work with.
My favorite part of I AM MARGARET MOORE is the writing -- Capin writes in such a poetic way and really brings the atmosphere of Marshall and its surroundings to life. While some readers won't connect with this particular style, I can see it being a good fit for those who enjoy darker novels in verse.
I think the pacing is also going to divide a lot of readers. From a logical standpoint, it seems like not much happens until the plot twist 2/3 through. On the other hand, the slow pacing of that first section of the book drew me in and got me invested, which made that plot twist hit that much harder. This book would probably be a better fit for readers who don't mind slower paced books, or are looking for something that feels a little more unsettling.
Ultimately, I found I AM MARGARET MOORE to be an impactful book about girls who feel silenced and that their ability to choose has been taken from them, all to protect the boys who put them in that situation in the first place. While the framing is unconventional, ultimately the book is about Margaret reclaiming her sense of self. This has potential to resonate with the readers who do connect to this book.
Thank you Wednesday Books for providing a copy for review.