Super unique noir murder mystery set in a mystical city with elves, draconids, mermaids, humans, and more. I want more more more about the history of this place and this city and how it came to be. But this was a GREAT opener to this world because Thompson doesn’t spend time forcing world building on you - she just tells the story and lets you pick up details along the way. I really enjoyed it and can’t wait for volume 2.
Less interesting and impactful than book 1. Slower story movement and the awe was diminished since I had already gotten used to the artistic style. I also appreciate Hades pointing out their age difference, but if anything, now I've just gotten the super ick about the direction of the love story.
The end of an era with Kelly Thompson’s incredible version of Carol. Highlights for me were the Fallen Avenger and the story in the future. I’ll miss Thompson’s Captain Marvel but I’m excited to see what’s next for her.
An attempted murder in the Bake-Off tent and one of the bakers must find the culprit while baking ahead of the competition. Cute but left something to be desired.
I wanted this to be amazing, and while the context and concept was incredible, the writing was not. While the flow improved in the second half of the book, I never felt a true depth in any of the 3 heroines. Any distinguishing character traits were very circumstantial rather than fully developed. This book did, however, peak my interest in learning more about black women who served in the world wars. Again, I loved the concept and the history. I wish I had loved the prose. Thanks to NetGalley and Harlequin Trade Publishing!
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
Reread November 2023: Glad I reread before Iron Flame. Even a few months later there was a lot I forgot!
August 2023: This is the most thrilling book I have read in ages. It took me right back to the excitement I felt reading Divergent or The Hunger Games for the first time. The story is non-stop action and fun, with a genuinely unique storyline, setting, magic system, and world building. I loved the little nuances that spoke to the way a world could be, and the 'modern' dialogue didn't bother me in the slightest. I cannot wait for book 2 and I'm so glad it's coming this year!!!
I’m the problem, it’s me. This book came to me at the wrong time in my life. If i had read it 10 years ago or maybe 10 years from now, I think I would love it. I also think the hype over this book ruined it a bit for me, because I was not emotionally prepared for how heartbreaking much of this story is. Zevin’s writing is beautiful, and her prose should absolutely be studied. I wasn’t a fan of the shifting timelines, and the sad moments were just too sad for me. But the storytelling was immaculate, and the characters were more complex than nearly anything else I’ve ever read. I do recommend, but don’t go in expecting the lighthearted book about friendship and video games that I was.
2.5 stars. Weakest in the series. Frustrating lack of plot. I take pretty big issue with the climax of a book getting resolved by someone thinking really hard about a problem for dozens of pages until they realize the error of their ways.
Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
This was the most daunting book I have read in a long, long time and I am really proud of myself for pushing through and finishing this masterpiece of a trilogy. The entire story is really expertly done, and my one big critique is that the final book could have been split into 2 or even 3 smaller books to make it less intimidating. Overall I highly recommend this series if you like high fantasy, want to read more books from the Middle East/North Africa, or like intricate, complex storylines.