Scan barcode
campbelle's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
lighthearted
reflective
sad
medium-paced
4.0
knod78's review
5.0
4.5 stars for me.
This story was so much more than the show. I am surprised, completely. I kind of wished they spent more time on the parts around their love and Saro's death. I loved that in the movie, but didn't get it in the book. However, I loved the after parts visiting Sicily as much as they did that we missed in the movie. I loved how her relationship with her mother-in-law developed into something special. I loved the cooking and farming. I want to plant fava beans myself. I loved to see her daughter and her become one with Aliminusa, entrenched into the culture. I loved at the end when her parents came to visit, the mule guy tells them that she is a part of this town. And I especially loved the recipes at the end.
But there was quite a bit of repetitive information and almost gave this 4 stars. I kept reading that she was looking at this with both grief and happiness and moving forward. There are so many times you can read it. Sorry. And I kind of wished there was more story to their love. Yes, it sucks to read the parts of the cancer and the illness, but I felt detached from Saro unlike how I felt in the show. He was a ghost in this book and I didn't really like it.
I do recommend this book and you will get something from the book even more than just watching the show. I can say honestly, it's different. And this book also reminds me why I have repeatedly told my husband that he's not allowed to die before me.
This story was so much more than the show. I am surprised, completely. I kind of wished they spent more time on the parts around their love and Saro's death. I loved that in the movie, but didn't get it in the book. However, I loved the after parts visiting Sicily as much as they did that we missed in the movie. I loved how her relationship with her mother-in-law developed into something special. I loved the cooking and farming. I want to plant fava beans myself. I loved to see her daughter and her become one with Aliminusa, entrenched into the culture. I loved at the end when her parents came to visit, the mule guy tells them that she is a part of this town. And I especially loved the recipes at the end.
But there was quite a bit of repetitive information and almost gave this 4 stars. I kept reading that she was looking at this with both grief and happiness and moving forward. There are so many times you can read it. Sorry. And I kind of wished there was more story to their love. Yes, it sucks to read the parts of the cancer and the illness, but I felt detached from Saro unlike how I felt in the show. He was a ghost in this book and I didn't really like it.
I do recommend this book and you will get something from the book even more than just watching the show. I can say honestly, it's different. And this book also reminds me why I have repeatedly told my husband that he's not allowed to die before me.
nypeapod's review
4.0
A love story
A beautiful love story. I would have liked to read more about the relationship between the child and parents. It is an emotionally difficult book to read at times.
A beautiful love story. I would have liked to read more about the relationship between the child and parents. It is an emotionally difficult book to read at times.
artbymonimack's review
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
informative
inspiring
reflective
sad
fast-paced
5.0
ebtdean's review
3.0
I’m torn between 3 and 4 stars for this. The story was well written and really beautiful. But the story jumped around so much between chapters and sections it was difficult to track. I feel as though the story would have been more impactful and enjoyable if it followed the path that the events happened. Granted, I think that much build up would have made it a more intensely sad book.
cavityfila's review against another edition
Not a bad book but too slow for me. DNF at 50%.